Refinance Break Even Calculator – When Does Refinancing Really Pay Off?
This Refinance Break Even Calculator is designed to help homeowners move beyond teaser rates and marketing headlines. Instead of looking only at a lower interest rate, it compares your current mortgage to a new refinance offer and shows how long it takes to recover closing costs, how much interest you could save and how much you may gain or lose over the time you actually keep the loan.
Refinancing can be a powerful tool, but it is not always the right choice. A refinance usually lowers your monthly payment by reducing the interest rate, extending the term, or both. At the same time, you pay closing costs and restart the amortization schedule. This calculator highlights the trade-off between up-front costs and future savings so you can make a more informed decision.
How the Refinance Break-Even Calculator Works
The calculator is organized into five specialized modes:
- Payment Savings Break-Even: Focuses on monthly payment savings and closing cost payback time.
- Interest Savings: Compares total interest on your current loan vs the refinance loan over their full terms.
- Costs vs Savings: Looks at closing costs vs savings over the years you expect to keep the loan.
- Refinance vs No Refinance: Runs a side-by-side amortization comparison over a custom holding period.
- Cash-In Refinance: Evaluates whether paying extra cash or discount points to buy down the rate is worth it.
By changing one input at a time, you can see how rate, term, closing costs and holding period influence your break-even point and long-term savings.
Mode 1: Payment Savings Break-Even
The Payment Savings Break-Even mode answers the classic question: “If I refinance, how many months will it take for my lower monthly payment to recover the closing costs?”
Payment Savings Break-Even Formula
Break-Even Months = Closing Costs ÷ Monthly Savings
Break-Even Years = Break-Even Months ÷ 12
Once you pass the break-even point, ongoing monthly savings become net savings. When you also enter years remaining on your current loan, the calculator estimates total net savings over that remaining term assuming you keep the refinance for the same duration.
Mode 2: Interest Savings Over the Loan Term
A lower monthly payment does not always mean you save interest. For example, stretching a 20-year loan back out to 30 years can reduce the payment while increasing total interest. The Interest Savings mode isolates the effect of rate and term by calculating monthly payments and total interest for both the current and new loans.
Interest and Payment Formula
Monthly Payment = Loan Amount × Monthly Rate ÷ (1 − (1 + Monthly Rate)−Number of Payments)
Total Interest = (Monthly Payment × Number of Payments) − Loan Amount
This mode shows whether your savings come from a genuinely lower interest rate, a longer term, or both. It also helps highlight situations where a lower rate but much longer term does not provide as much benefit as expected.
Mode 3: Closing Costs vs Monthly Savings
Refinancing almost always involves closing costs: lender fees, appraisal, title, taxes and more. The Costs vs Savings mode focuses on theationship between those costs and your monthly payment savings over the years you expect to keep the loan.
Cost Recovery and ROI Formula
Break-Even Years = Break-Even Months ÷ 12
Gross Savings = Monthly Savings × Holding Period Months
Net Savings = Gross Savings − Closing Costs
Return on Costs% = (Net Savings ÷ Closing Costs) × 100
This mode is particularly useful if you expect to move or refinance again within a set number of years. If the break-even time is much longer than your planned holding period, refinancing may not be attractive, even with a lower rate.
Mode 4: Refinance vs No Refinance (Amortization Comparison)
The Refinance vs No Refinance mode takes a more complete view by simulating both loans over a chosen holding period. It calculates monthly payments, tracks principal and interest month by month and shows how much you will pay under each scenario over the period you care.
Loan Comparison Logic
1. Calculate Monthly Payment from Loan Amount, Rate and Term.
2. Simulate Monthly Amortization up to the earlier of holding period or loan payoff.
3. Track Total Paid, Total Interest and Remaining Balance.
4. Add Closing Costs to Refinance Scenario Cost.
The calculator then reports the total cost for staying with your current loan versus refinancing, including closing costs, and shows the net savings (or additional cost) over the holding period.
Mode 5: Cash-In Refinance and Discount Points
In a cash-in refinance, you pay extra at closing to reduce your loan balance or buy discount points that lower your interest rate. The key question is whether the extra cash paid up front will pay for itself through lower monthly payments.
Cash-In Analysis Formula
Total Cash In = Points Cost + Extra Fees
Monthly Payment Without Points = Payment at Higher Rate
Monthly Payment With Points = Payment at Lower Rate
Monthly Savings = Payment Without Points − Payment With Points
Break-Even Months = Total Cash In ÷ Monthly Savings
Net Benefit = (Monthly Savings × Holding Period Months) − Total Cash In
If the break-even time is shorter than your expected holding period and net benefit is positive, paying points or extra cash may be attractive. If not, keeping more cash in reserve might be a better choice.
When Does a Refinance Make Sense?
A refinance is more likely to make sense when closing costs are modest compared with monthly savings, you expect to keep the loan long enough to pass the break-even point and the new rate materially reduces interest without extending the term too far. On the other hand, if you plan to move soon or if most of the payment reduction comes from adding years back to the loan, the long-term benefit may be limited.
How to Use This Tool Effectively
- Start with the Payment Savings Break-Even tab to see how many months it takes to recover closing costs.
- Use the Interest Savings tab to check whether the new loan genuinely reduces total interest paid.
- Switch to Costs vs Savings and enter the number of years you realistically expect to keep the loan.
- Run the Refinance vs No Refinance comparison to see total cost over your holding period, including closing costs.
- Use the Cash-In Refinance tab if your lender offers discount points or you are considering paying extra at closing.
- Test several scenarios by changing rates, terms and holding periods before making any commitment.
Related Tools from MyTimeCalculator
For broader mortgage and budgeting analysis, you may also find these tools useful:
Refinance Break Even Calculator FAQs
Frequently Asked Questions Refinancing and Break-Even Analysis
Find straightforward answers to common questions refinance break-even, closing costs, interest savings and how to interpret the results.
Not necessarily. A lower payment can come from a lower rate, a longer term or both. Extending the term may increase total interest even if the rate is lower. That is why it is important to look at total interest and total cost, not just the monthly payment difference.
If you plan to sell the or refinance again before reaching break-even, you may never fully recover the closing costs. In that case, refinancing might not be worthwhile unless there are other strong reasons for doing it.
Paying costs in cash avoids interest on those costs but requires more up-front money. Rolling costs into the loan keeps cash available but increases the loan balance and interest. The best choice depends on your cash reserves, goals and risk tolerance; the calculator can help you estimate the long-term impact but cannot replace personal financial advice.
Break-even estimates are only as accurate as the inputs you provide. Changes in rates, prepayments, future refinances, or early payoff can all shift the real outcome. Treat the results as planning scenarios rather than guarantees and update them if your assumptions change.
No. The calculator focuses on principal and interest. If your escrowed taxes and insurance are similar before and after refinancing, the change in principal and interest is usually the main driver of payment savings. For a complete budget, you should still account for taxes and insurance separately.
The calculator is built around standard fixed-rate amortizing loans. Adjustable-rate mortgages, prepayment penalties, and extra principal payments are not modeled in detail. For those cases, treat the results as approximations and consider more specialized advice if needed.